2026-09-17
Crucial P510 holds first at 9.1 and the ranking carries forward. I have spent the last few weeks on price and timing, so today I want to settle the hardware question readers ask me most in this market: is PCIe 5.0 worth paying for, or does a PCIe 4.0 drive do the job?
For a gaming PC or a general desktop, a fast PCIe 4.0 drive or an efficient entry PCIe 5.0 drive covers everything. Game loading depends mostly on random read performance and on how well the game engine streams assets, and the difference between a good Gen4 drive and a flagship Gen5 drive in load times is a second or two in most titles. That is why my top four all score between 8.0 and 9.6 on random I/O while posting 9.0 or better on price per terabyte. The P510 is a DRAM-less PCIe 5.0 design that runs cool, with an 8.8 thermal score, and that makes it an easy fit in a motherboard slot under a hot graphics card.
A flagship Gen5 drive earns its price in one situation: large sustained writes. If you copy multi-hundred-gigabyte video projects, move virtual machine images or cache large AI model files, sustained write after the cache fills is the number you feel. The Crucial T710 scores 9.4 there with 9.4 random I/O, and the Samsung 9100 PRO posts 9.2 and 9.6. Those drives shorten a real workday for the people who need them.
With NAND pricing still elevated, that distinction is worth money. A flagship Gen5 2TB drive costs noticeably more per terabyte than the P510 or the KIOXIA EXCERIA PLUS G4, and for a player that premium buys very little you would ever notice. Spend it on capacity. A 2TB P510 that holds your full library does more for daily use than a faster 1TB drive that forces you to uninstall games.
Gen4 class speed covers gaming
Load time gaps between a good mainstream drive and a flagship Gen5 run a second or two in most games.
P510 runs cool under a hot GPU
Its 8.8 thermal score and 9.6 price per terabyte keep it first at 9.1.
Flagship Gen5 is for sustained writes
Crucial T710 at 9.4 and Samsung 9100 PRO at 9.2 on sustained write pay off for video, VMs and large model files.
Spend the premium on capacity
In today's NAND market a larger mainstream drive delivers more daily value than a faster smaller one.