πŸ† TopRankLand
← All Rankings
Electronics

Best Smart Home Hubs 2026: Ranked by What Survives the Shutdown

Ten smart home hubs ranked on what keeps working after the vendor closes the cloud, which Matter version actually ships, and who charges for their own API, in the year Belkin killed Wemo and Samsung put SmartThings API access behind a $4.99 monthly fee.

Last updated: 2026-09-18 Β· 10 entries tracked daily

Rank Trend β€” Top 10

Lower = better rank. Showing last 8 days.

Current Rankings

#1
$199 9.1/10

The open source hub that runs every automation on the box in your own house, with no vendor account required to arm a single one of them. Nabu Casa raised it from $99 to $199 on 8 January 2026 and published the RAM cost breakdown behind the increase.

What Still Works After the Cloud Shuts Down 9.8
Local Automation Engine 9.7
Built-in Zigbee, Z-Wave & Thread Radios 6.0
Matter Version Actually Shipping 9.0
API Access & Subscription Policy 9.9
Setup Effort for a Normal Household 6.5
Price Against What You Actually Own 8.6
Taiwan Retail Availability 5.5
#2
$179.95-$199.95 8.8/10

A fully local automation engine with Z-Wave 800 Long Range, Zigbee 3.0, Matter 1.5 and Wi-Fi radios all inside the case, priced at $179.95 direct from Hubitat.

What Still Works After the Cloud Shuts Down 9.6
Local Automation Engine 9.4
Built-in Zigbee, Z-Wave & Thread Radios 9.5
Matter Version Actually Shipping 9.6
API Access & Subscription Policy 9.2
Setup Effort for a Normal Household 6.8
Price Against What You Actually Own 8.4
Taiwan Retail Availability 4.5
#3
$399-$449 8.4/10

Seven radios in one puck, Z-Wave Plus, Zigbee, Thread, Matter, Wi-Fi, Bluetooth and infrared, with the Flow automation engine executing on-device. Launched December 2025 with double the memory at the same €399.

What Still Works After the Cloud Shuts Down 9.0
Local Automation Engine 9.2
Built-in Zigbee, Z-Wave & Thread Radios 9.8
Matter Version Actually Shipping 8.8
API Access & Subscription Policy 7.6
Setup Effort for a Normal Household 8.6
Price Against What You Actually Own 6.8
Taiwan Retail Availability 4.0
#4
$109-$149.99 7.9/10

A Matter controller and Thread border router with a Zigbee 3.0 radio, an IR blaster and Power over Ethernet, and it keeps a stored set of local automations running when the internet drops.

What Still Works After the Cloud Shuts Down 7.6
Local Automation Engine 7.8
Built-in Zigbee, Z-Wave & Thread Radios 8.2
Matter Version Actually Shipping 8.4
API Access & Subscription Policy 6.8
Setup Effort for a Normal Household 8.8
Price Against What You Actually Own 8.6
Taiwan Retail Availability 8.5
#5
$99.99 7.2/10

A $99.99 control panel with a 2.4-inch IPS screen and a physical dial, a Β±0.2Β°C temperature sensor, an IR blaster for air conditioners, and a Matter bridge that exposes 30 secondary devices to any Matter platform.

What Still Works After the Cloud Shuts Down 6.6
Local Automation Engine 6.8
Built-in Zigbee, Z-Wave & Thread Radios 6.4
Matter Version Actually Shipping 8.0
API Access & Subscription Policy 7.4
Setup Effort for a Normal Household 9.2
Price Against What You Actually Own 8.8
Taiwan Retail Availability 8.8
#6
$127-$149.99 6.6/10

The hardware Samsung handed to Aeotec after retiring its own hub line, carrying Zigbee, Z-Wave, Thread and Matter radios and running SmartThings Edge drivers locally for up to 100 Zigbee and 100 Z-Wave devices.

What Still Works After the Cloud Shuts Down 6.8
Local Automation Engine 7.4
Built-in Zigbee, Z-Wave & Thread Radios 9.0
Matter Version Actually Shipping 8.6
API Access & Subscription Policy 4.0
Setup Effort for a Normal Household 7.8
Price Against What You Actually Own 6.4
Taiwan Retail Availability 4.2
#7
$59.99-$79.99 6.2/10

A 15W wireless charger that doubles as a Matter controller and Thread border router, and the cheapest way into SmartThings if your appliances are already Samsung.

What Still Works After the Cloud Shuts Down 5.4
Local Automation Engine 6.2
Built-in Zigbee, Z-Wave & Thread Radios 5.0
Matter Version Actually Shipping 8.6
API Access & Subscription Policy 4.0
Setup Effort for a Normal Household 9.0
Price Against What You Actually Own 8.2
Taiwan Retail Availability 6.5
#8
$199-$249 6.0/10

A Thread border router and Apple Home hub that keeps HomeKit automations running locally, and the device that kept paired Wemo hardware alive after Belkin closed the Wemo cloud. Apple moved it to $199 on 25 June 2026.

What Still Works After the Cloud Shuts Down 8.4
Local Automation Engine 7.0
Built-in Zigbee, Z-Wave & Thread Radios 4.5
Matter Version Actually Shipping 7.6
API Access & Subscription Policy 5.2
Setup Effort for a Normal Household 9.4
Price Against What You Actually Own 4.2
Taiwan Retail Availability 9.5
#9
$109.99-$179.99 5.6/10

An 8-inch wall panel with Zigbee, Matter, Thread and Sidewalk radios built in, designed as a single touchscreen dashboard for an Alexa house, and discounted to $109.99 during June 2026.

What Still Works After the Cloud Shuts Down 4.2
Local Automation Engine 5.0
Built-in Zigbee, Z-Wave & Thread Radios 8.4
Matter Version Actually Shipping 7.4
API Access & Subscription Policy 4.4
Setup Effort for a Normal Household 8.6
Price Against What You Actually Own 6.8
Taiwan Retail Availability 3.5
#10
$99.99 5.2/10

Google's $99.99 replacement for Nest Mini and Nest Audio, shipping 25 June 2026 with an on-device NPU for Gemini and a Thread 1.3 border router, with the advanced Gemini features sitting inside Google Home Premium.

What Still Works After the Cloud Shuts Down 3.8
Local Automation Engine 4.4
Built-in Zigbee, Z-Wave & Thread Radios 5.2
Matter Version Actually Shipping 7.0
API Access & Subscription Policy 4.2
Setup Effort for a Normal Household 9.2
Price Against What You Actually Own 6.6
Taiwan Retail Availability 3.2

Today's Analysis Β· 2026-09-18

Home Assistant Green holds first at 9.1 and the ranking carries forward. The product news worth a hub owner's attention this week is a sensor. On 16 September MatterDevices.io covered Aqara's FP400, a 60GHz mmWave presence sensor that tracks up to 10 people at once across an area up to 10 by 8 metres, divides a room into a 0.5 metre grid with up to eight custom zones, and reports posture as sitting, standing or lying down.

The detail that matters for this ranking is the radio. The FP400 speaks Thread or Zigbee and exposes itself over Matter, and its predecessor, the FP2, ran on Wi-Fi. On Thread it pairs through any Thread border router with no Aqara hub required. That makes it a clean example of where hubs earn their keep in 2026: the sensor is cheap and standard, and the intelligence lives in the hub that turns "two people on the sofa, one lying down" into lights, climate and alerts.

That is exactly why Home Assistant Green keeps first. Zone and posture data is only useful if your automation engine can branch on it, and Home Assistant's automations handle multiple conditions, numeric states and per-zone triggers with the most flexibility in this ranking. Add a Connect ZBT-2 adapter and the Green gains a Thread radio as well. Hubitat Elevation C-8 Pro at rank 2 is my pick for someone who wants that logic running locally on a box that rarely needs attention. Aqara Hub M3 at rank 4 is the simplest path for an FP400 on Zigbee, since it unlocks the full Aqara feature set there.

One practical tip. Presence sensors generate a lot of state changes, so before you add a multi-person sensor, check your hub's history retention settings. On Home Assistant I exclude raw coordinate entities from the recorder and keep only the zone occupancy entities, which keeps the database small on the Green's built-in storage.

Aqara lists a 10 percent Amazon code through 28 September, and Prime Big Deal Days lands on 6 and 7 October.

Aqara FP400 arrives on Matter

A 60GHz mmWave sensor tracking up to 10 people over 10 by 8 metres, with eight custom zones and posture detection.

Thread or Zigbee, no Wi-Fi

On Thread it pairs through any border router with no Aqara hub. On Zigbee, the Aqara Hub M3 unlocks full features.

Home Assistant Green keeps first at 9.1

Zone and posture data needs an automation engine that can branch on it, and Home Assistant is the most flexible here.

Trim the recorder

Keep zone occupancy entities and exclude raw coordinates so the Green's storage stays lean.

Deal window

Aqara's Amazon code runs to 28 September, and Prime Big Deal Days follows on 6 and 7 October.

References

Update History

2026-09-17

Home Assistant Green holds first at 9.1 and the ranking carries forward. The policy news worth reading this week comes from Beijing. On 15 September eight Chinese government departments, including the Ministry of Commerce, issued an action plan with seven measures to lift smart home appliance consumption, covering supply, standards, consumer subsidies, elderly friendly products and recycling, according to Caixin.

That matters to hub buyers far outside China, because a large share of the sensors, plugs and switches that feed a hub are designed and built there. Aqara and SwitchBot each hold a spot on this list, and a subsidy program at home tends to push those makers toward bigger production runs and faster product cycles. The standards measure is the one I will watch most closely. Firmer national interoperability standards usually arrive in exported products as better Matter certification coverage.

The elderly friendly measure is the part I find most useful as a reviewer, because it describes a real use case for a hub. A presence sensor that notices no movement in the kitchen by 10 in the morning, a door sensor that reports an open front door at night, a large button that calls family. Those automations need a hub that runs locally and keeps working during an internet outage, and that is exactly the job Home Assistant Green does best. It processes everything on the box in your home, it speaks Zigbee and Matter through the right add on, and its automation editor handles conditions and schedules with room to spare.

Hubitat Elevation C-8 Pro at 8.8 is the pick for anyone who wants that same local reliability with a more guided setup. Aqara Hub M3 at fourth stays the easiest entry point for a household already buying Aqara sensors, since it is a Matter controller and Thread border router in one box. I will revisit scores once subsidized products start appearing with their spec sheets.

China's 15 September plan

Eight departments issued seven measures on smart home consumption, covering supply, standards, subsidies, elderly friendly products and recycling.

Why hub buyers should care

Many sensors and switches that feed a hub come from Chinese makers such as Aqara and SwitchBot, so subsidies shape their product cycles.

Care automations need local hubs

Inactivity alerts and night door warnings must keep running during an outage, which is where Home Assistant Green excels.

Hubitat for guided setup

The C-8 Pro at 8.8 offers the same local processing with a friendlier setup path.

Aqara M3 as entry point

A Matter controller and Thread border router in one box makes it the simple choice for Aqara households.

2026-09-16

Home Assistant Green keeps first place at 9.1 and the ranking carries forward. The most useful thing I can hand you today is a calendar, because the next three weeks decide what a hub costs and what it will be able to do.

Amazon holds a hardware event in New York on 30 September covering Echo, Kindle, Fire TV, Ring and Blink, all built around Alexa+. The Amazon Echo Hub sits ninth here, and it is the one product on this list most likely to be refreshed or repositioned that day. Prime Big Deal Days follow on 6 and 7 October. Anyone who wants an Alexa centred hub should let both dates pass before ordering.

Apple shipped iOS 27 on 14 September with Siri rebuilt as a standalone app trained on Google Gemini models, and the deepest features reserved for A17 Pro silicon and newer. That lands on the Apple TV 4K at eighth place, since voice is how most households actually touch a Home setup day to day.

Those two stories share a shape. The assistant layer keeps moving, the cloud keeps changing its mind, and your lights still need to come on at dusk. That is the whole argument for Home Assistant Green at the top. Its automation engine runs on the box sitting in your living room, the API is documented and open, and a dropped internet connection costs you remote access while local schedules keep firing.

Hubitat Elevation C-8 Pro at 8.8 is the pick for anyone who wants that same local behaviour with Zigbee, Z-Wave and Thread radios already inside, so a house full of older sensors joins without extra dongles.

For readers in Taiwan, Aqara Hub M3 at 7.9 remains the practical choice. It is on shelves here, it speaks Zigbee and Thread, and it keeps a stored set of automations running when the network drops during a typhoon.

Two dates worth waiting for

Amazon refreshes Echo, Ring and Blink at its New York event on 30 September, and Prime Big Deal Days land on 6 and 7 October. Alexa focused buyers get better prices and better information by waiting three weeks.

iOS 27 moves Siri into its own app

Apple's 14 September release rebuilds Siri as a standalone app trained with Google Gemini models, with the deepest features gated to A17 Pro silicon and newer. Apple TV 4K owners at eighth place feel it first.

Local automation is the hedge

Home Assistant Green holds first at 9.1 because its schedules and rules execute on hardware you own. Assistant platforms can be rebuilt overnight and your dusk lighting still runs on time.

Aqara Hub M3 for Taiwan homes

At 7.9 it is the top-half hub with real retail presence in Taiwan, carrying Zigbee and Thread radios and locally stored automations that survive a typhoon night without internet.

2026-09-15

Home Assistant Green keeps first place at 9.1 and the whole ranking carries forward. With IFA wrapped, I went through Matterhome's verified roundup of the show's smart home news, and the hub story it tells is the clearest argument yet for buying a hub whose job is fully documented.

Anker introduced a local AI hub meant to coordinate close to 100 of its own products plus third party devices, and it says the hub works with hundreds of Matter products alongside Apple Home, Alexa, Google Home and Home Assistant. It is due later in 2026 with pricing still to come. Matterhome points out that Anker has yet to say whether it acts as a Matter controller, a bridge or a Thread border router. Those three roles decide what a hub can actually run for you, so I will wait for that spec sheet before it gets a score.

Shelly announced a planned free firmware update, roughly three months out, that lets eligible Gen4 devices move from Wi-Fi to Thread while keeping local API access. Remote access will still need a Thread border router in the house. Aqara also previewed its Edge Hub M300 before the show days.

Every one of those announcements points back to the same need: a hub that runs automations locally and shows you your Thread network. Home Assistant Green does both today, and the 2026.9 Matter map added this month makes border router problems visible on one screen. That is why it stays first.

Hubitat Elevation C-8 Pro holds second at 8.8 for local Zigbee and Z-Wave automation with less tinkering. Homey Pro (2026) stays third at 8.4, and the Aqara Hub M3 keeps fourth at 7.9 as the value Thread and Matter hub that Taiwan buyers can find locally.

My advice: buy the hub for the roles it performs today, and treat any AI hub with an undefined Matter role as a product to revisit after reviews.

IFA hubs need clearer specs

Anker's new local AI hub claims work with hundreds of Matter products, but its role as controller, bridge or border router is still undocumented, so it stays unranked for now.

Shelly Gen4 heads to Thread

A free update due in about three months lets eligible Shelly Gen4 devices switch to Thread with local API access intact. Plan for a Thread border router before it lands.

Home Assistant Green holds first

Local automations plus the new 2026.9 Matter map keep it at 9.1. It already does the jobs the IFA hubs are still promising.

Aqara Hub M3 for Taiwan homes

At 7.9 it remains the most practical Thread and Matter hub you can buy from local Taiwan retailers, and it pairs directly with Aqara sensors.

2026-09-14

Home Assistant Green holds first at 9.1 and the ranking is unchanged. The most relevant software news came from Home Assistant itself: the 2026.9 release on September 2 added a visual Matter network map, which shows every Matter device, its Thread or Wi-Fi connection, and the border routers carrying it on a single screen.

That feature matters more than it sounds. The hardest part of running Matter over Thread in a real home is diagnosing why one sensor keeps dropping, and until now that information lived in a separate server interface most people never opened. A map that shows which border router a door sensor depends on turns an evening of guesswork into a two-minute fix. Home Assistant Green gets it on day one with processing that stays local, which is exactly why it leads.

The same release upgraded the built-in security dashboard with an Active alerts section that appears only when something needs attention, such as an open door or a triggered smoke detector, with severity levels and pinned favorites. It also lets integrations that speak Modbus build their configuration through the UI, which helps anyone connecting solar inverters or heat pumps.

Hubitat Elevation C-8 Pro stays second at 8.8. It runs automations locally with Zigbee and Z-Wave radios built in, and it is the hub I recommend to people who want local control with less tinkering.

Homey Pro (2026) holds third at 8.4 for its polished app and broad radio support, and the Aqara Hub M3 holds fourth at 7.9 as the strongest value for a Thread and Matter home, particularly for Taiwan buyers who can find Aqara gear locally.

My advice this week: if you already run Home Assistant, update to 2026.9 and open the Matter map before you buy another border router. If you are starting fresh, Home Assistant Green remains the safest long-term purchase in this category.

Home Assistant 2026.9 adds a Matter map

Released September 2, it shows every Matter device, its Thread or Wi-Fi link and its border router on one screen.

Security dashboard gets Active alerts

Alerts appear only when a door is open or a detector triggers, with severity levels and pinned favorites.

Home Assistant Green holds first

9.1, because local processing keeps working whatever happens to a cloud service.

Aqara Hub M3 for Taiwan buyers

Fourth at 7.9, the best-value Thread and Matter hub you can buy locally.

2026-09-11

IFA gave this category its most useful week of the year, and it strengthens the case for the ranking as it stands. Home Assistant Green holds first at 9.1 because local control is the only property in smart home that ages well. Everything else here depends on a company continuing to run a server, and I have watched too many hubs turn into paperweights when a business model changed.

Berlin was full of evidence that the standards layer is finally arriving. Shelly demonstrated turning a Thread radio into a full IP network and made its wall display a Matter controller. Tuya showed Matter cameras, bridging and energy monitoring across its manufacturing partners, which is how a standard actually reaches shelves. Heiman showed the first hardware demonstration of zero-power NFC commissioning.

Hubitat Elevation C-8 Pro stays at 8.8 as the local-first option for people who want a supported product with a support line. Homey Pro at 8.4 remains the most approachable of the serious hubs, and its protocol coverage genuinely reduces the number of bridges cluttering a shelf.

My advice for this month is to buy for the protocols you own today and treat Matter maturity as a bonus that arrives later. The demonstrations in Berlin were real, and shipping firmware across a hundred brands takes another year.

Local control is the only durable property here

Home Assistant Green keeps working when a vendor changes its business model or retires a cloud service. Every hub that depends on someone else running a server carries an expiry date you cannot see.

Berlin showed the standards layer actually arriving

Thread radios becoming full IP networks, Matter controllers in wall displays, and zero-power NFC commissioning on real hardware. These are the unglamorous steps that decide whether Matter becomes ordinary.

Tuya matters more than its brand recognition suggests

It supplies the manufacturing partners behind a great many own-brand devices. Matter cameras and bridging across that base is how the standard reaches shelves in volume.

Buy for the protocols you own today

Firmware across a hundred brands takes another year to ship. Choose a hub that speaks Zigbee and Z-Wave to the devices already in your house, and let Matter maturity arrive as a bonus.

2026-09-09

IFA gave this category its most substantial week of the year. Matter Alpha's show coverage focused on local AI arriving in hubs and cameras, and both UGREEN and Anker showed hub platforms pairing Matter control with local storage. Aqara updated the M3 line alongside new Thread and Zigbee lighting, and SwitchBot showed the Hub Mini Matter with a Lock Ultra Max.

The ranking holds because none of that changes the fundamental argument. Home Assistant Green stays first at 9.1 because it is the only hub here that does not depend on a company continuing to care about your house. Everything runs locally, integrations exist for devices manufacturers abandoned years ago, and nothing stops working when a cloud service is retired. In a category where products get discontinued and servers get switched off, that independence is the feature.

Hubitat Elevation C-8 Pro at 8.8 is the pick for someone who wants local control with a gentler setup process. It is genuinely easier to live with than Home Assistant while keeping the same local-first principle.

The direction the whole industry showed at IFA, moving processing onto the hub rather than a data center, is the direction Home Assistant has been going for a decade. The rest of the market is catching up to a position that was correct all along.

Home Assistant wins because it outlives the companies that made your devices

Everything runs locally, integrations exist for hardware manufacturers abandoned years ago, and nothing breaks when a cloud service is retired. In a category defined by discontinued products and switched-off servers, that independence is the feature, not a technicality.

IFA confirmed local processing is where the industry is heading

Show coverage highlighted local AI in hubs and cameras, with UGREEN and Anker pairing Matter control with local storage. That is the direction Home Assistant has held for a decade. The rest of the market is catching up to a position that was correct from the start.

Hubitat is the gentler route to local control

At 8.8 it keeps the local-first principle while being genuinely easier to live with than Home Assistant. If you want your home to keep working during an internet outage but do not want a configuration project, this is the hub to buy.

2026-09-08

Buy a smart home hub in 2026 and you are buying two separate things. One is a box of radios. The other is a license the seller can revoke, and this year gave us three dated examples of a seller doing exactly that.

Belkin closed the Wemo cloud on 31 January 2026. Every Wemo plug, switch, bulb, sensor and baby monitor lost its app, its remote access and its Alexa and Google voice control on that date. One category of Wemo hardware kept running: devices already paired to Apple Home before the deadline still respond through the Home app, because HomeKit control is local. That is the cleanest lesson of the year, and I have built this entire ranking around it.

Futurehome AS was declared bankrupt on 20 May 2025. FHSD Connect AS bought the platform out of the estate and, as of 26 June, put a mandatory 1,188 NOK annual fee, roughly $117, on approximately 30,000 Smarthub II owners who had already paid in full for their hardware. Owners who decline receive a firmware update that removes local network functions.

Then Samsung. In late June it announced that SmartThings API access moves to paid tiers in October 2026, with a $4.99 monthly plan for individual non-commercial developers and separate commercial tiers. Free access runs through Q3, and Samsung says no new limits or shutoffs arrive before October. The rate limits, the call ceilings and the usage threshold that triggers billing have all not been published, and that missing number is a risk that transfers straight to anyone whose Home Assistant setup leans on a SmartThings integration.

So my ranking factor here is survivability. For every hub I asked one question: with the vendor's cloud dark, what still fires? Local automations, offline triggers, direct Zigbee and Z-Wave links, local Matter control, remote access. Home Assistant Green keeps all five. Hubitat C-8 Pro keeps all five. At the other end sit hubs whose automation engine lives on someone else's server, and those hubs go quiet the moment that server does. Every list I read this year sorted on device compatibility counts. I sort on what you own after the announcement.

Home Assistant Green is worth the $199 it now costs, because nobody has the power to switch it off

Nabu Casa raised the Green from $99 to $199 on 8 January 2026, blaming component costs and specifically RAM, which matches every other price move I have tracked in hardware this year. I still rank it first, and the reason is structural. The automation engine, the device drivers and the dashboard all run on the box sitting in your home, the source code is public, and the community can fork and maintain it if the company behind it ever stops. There is no account to lose, no API tier to fall out of, and no bankruptcy estate that can sell the right to charge you a fee for the thing you already bought. Add a Zigbee or Z-Wave USB dongle for around thirty dollars and it covers the same protocol range as hubs costing twice as much. The one real cost is your evening: this is the hub that expects you to learn its automation model, and I would give it a weekend before you start moving door locks onto it.

1 October 2026 is a hard date on the calendar, and it lands on SmartThings households

Samsung's announcement is specific about the parts that cost money and vague about the parts that determine how much. Individual non-commercial developers pay $4.99 a month, commercial tiers are separate and unpriced, free access runs to the end of Q3, and Samsung has confirmed nothing turns off before October. What is still unpublished: the rate limits, the API call ceilings, and the usage level that pushes a household from free into paid. If your smart home is a SmartThings Station or an Aeotec hub bridged into Home Assistant, that unpublished threshold is your exposure. I score both of those hubs down on API policy for this reason alone, and I would use the free window between now and 30 September to check whether your automations can be rebuilt on direct Zigbee, Z-Wave or local Matter connections.

Hubitat C-8 Pro is the one hub shipping Matter 1.5 with every radio already inside the case

Matter 1.5 landed in November and brought cameras, closures and expanded energy management into the standard. Most hubs on sale today are still shipping 1.2 or 1.3 and promising firmware. The C-8 Pro lists Matter 1.5 alongside Z-Wave 800 Long Range, Zigbee 3.0, Bluetooth and Wi-Fi in a single $179.95 box, and its automation engine runs entirely on the device with no cloud dependency for rule execution. For a household that wants local control and a working setup on the first evening, this is the hub I recommend most often. Hubitat's Rule Machine is a genuine interface with dropdowns and conditions, so you get most of what Home Assistant offers without editing a YAML file.

Homey Pro carries seven radios, and that is the entire argument for its $399

The December 2025 refresh doubled the memory and held the price at €399, which in a year of memory-driven price rises is its own kind of achievement. Inside are Z-Wave Plus, Zigbee, Thread, Matter, Wi-Fi, Bluetooth and infrared, and the Flow automation engine executes on the device so scenes keep firing during an internet outage. If your house has accumulated a decade of mixed-protocol gear, including infrared air conditioners and Bluetooth sensors, this is the one box that talks to all of it without a single dongle hanging off a USB port. I rank it third purely on price per protocol. Buy it when the protocol spread is the problem you are actually solving.

Pair locally on day one, and the shutdown announcement becomes somebody else's news

The Wemo owners who came through 31 January intact were the ones who had paired to Apple Home before the deadline, which meant control never routed through Belkin's servers. Apply that rule to whatever you buy. Prefer a hub with its own Zigbee and Z-Wave radios so your sensors talk to hardware you own. Prefer Matter devices commissioned to a local controller. Keep at least one automation path, lights, locks and alarms, that never touches a vendor account. I hold the Apple TV 4K in this ranking for exactly that reason even at $199, because its Thread border router and local HomeKit execution have now been tested in public by an actual shutdown, and they passed.