2026-10-05
Transparent Labs Whey Protein Isolate keeps the top spot because it still has the cleanest label in this category: no artificial sweeteners, no proprietary blends, and a 9.9 purity score that nothing else here matches. At $65 it's priced like a premium product, which is the only real knock against it.
Optimum Nutrition's Gold Standard 100% Whey remains second on the strength of its near-perfect mixability and the best value-per-serving ratio of any major brand, which is why it's still the best-selling whey powder in the US by volume.
The two FDA allergy alerts I flagged last update, New Capstone's undeclared milk issue and Orgain's undeclared peanut residue in a single batch, remain active recalls as of this week. Neither Transparent Labs nor Optimum Nutrition are involved, so I haven't touched their scores, but Orgain's position at the bottom of this list reflects both its lower purity score and this recall history.
I didn't find new recall or safety news this week beyond those two ongoing alerts. If you have a milk or peanut allergy, double-check lot numbers against the FDA listings before using any powder you already have at home, regardless of brand.
My rankings are unchanged from last week.
Transparent Labs still has the cleanest label here
No artificial sweeteners, no proprietary blends, and a 9.9 purity score, the $65 price is the only real tradeoff for that transparency.
Two FDA allergy alerts remain active
New Capstone's undeclared milk and Orgain's undeclared peanut residue recalls are both still open this week, worth checking lot numbers against if either brand is in your kitchen.