2026-10-05
Bitwarden holds the top spot, and this week brings a new wrinkle worth separating from an actual breach: phishing emails impersonating Bitwarden, LastPass, and 1Password have been circulating more than usual this October, including one that targeted a C-suite employee at a cybersecurity firm by spoofing a 1Password notification to hunt for a master password. That is a real threat to individual users who click the wrong link, but it is social engineering aimed at people, not a compromise of any vault or any of these companies' own infrastructure, and I keep that distinction central to how I score breach record here. Bitwarden's 9.8 real cost score and genuinely free tier keep it first; the brief npm supply chain incident earlier this year, where a malicious CLI package was live for roughly 90 minutes before removal, still never touched vault infrastructure. 1Password stays second on a 9.6 breach record score built from a clean history across repeated independent audits, a history that makes it the obvious spoofing target precisely because its brand signals trust. Proton Pass holds third, its 9.5 real cost score and 9.3 encryption score make it the strongest free tier option for anyone already inside Proton's ecosystem. LastPass remains last at 6.2 specifically because its 3.2 breach record score still reflects the aftermath of its 2022 incident, and this month's phishing wave targeting it too is a reminder that rebuilding trust takes far longer than any single patch cycle. I am holding every rank steady again this cycle. The lesson from this month's phishing wave is the same one I'd give regardless of which provider you use: verify any password-reset or master-password prompt through the app directly, never through an email link.
October's phishing wave targets people, not vaults
Spoofed emails impersonating Bitwarden, LastPass, and 1Password circulated through October, including one targeting a cybersecurity firm's C-suite, but none of these represent an actual breach of vault infrastructure.
Bitwarden's CLI supply chain scare still wasn't a vault breach
A malicious npm package impersonated Bitwarden's CLI for about 90 minutes before removal earlier this year, a real incident that targeted a package registry, not the vault itself.
1Password's clean audit history makes it a prime spoofing target
A 9.6 breach record score built on repeated independent audits is exactly why 1Password's brand gets impersonated in phishing attempts, trust is what attackers are trying to borrow.
LastPass still pays for 2022, and this month proves it
A 3.2 breach record score keeps LastPass last; being targeted again by this month's phishing wave is a reminder that rebuilding user trust takes far longer than shipping a fix.