2026-10-05
Camp Chef's Gridiron 36 and Traeger's Flatrock 3-Zone stay tied at the top with matching 9.3 scores, and I'm keeping them there because nothing changed this week that would justify breaking the tie either way. The Gridiron's 9.6 grease management score still comes from a rear grease channel design that's genuinely easier to clean than the front trough most competitors use, and that single design choice is still doing the work of keeping it at the top through a full autumn of new entrants. Traeger's Flatrock matches it with a 9.6 heat control score built on independent zone management that lets you run a hot zone and a low zone side by side without one bleeding into the other. Blackstone's Original 36 Omnivore holds third with a 9.7 value score, still the best on this list, and it remains the right call for anyone who wants most of what the top two offer without paying the premium those heat control refinements command. Weber's Slate 36 sits fourth on a 9.5 build quality score, full stainless construction that outlasts the painted steel bodies lower on this list in outdoor conditions, though its 7.9 value score reflects exactly what that durability costs. Traeger's Irontop 4-Burner holds fifth, a genuinely solid griddle, but it's still competing against two models with a longer proven track record, and this ranking keeps rewarding that history over a newer release until the newer release earns its own.
Gridiron 36's grease design still justifies the tie at the top
A 9.6 grease management score comes from a rear channel that's easier to clean than the front trough most competitors use, the same advantage that's held through a full season of new entrants.
Flatrock 3-Zone matches it on independent heat control
A 9.6 heat control score reflects zone management that keeps a hot zone and a low zone running side by side without either bleeding into the other.
Blackstone Omnivore remains the value leader
A 9.7 value score, the best on this list, makes it the right call for buyers who want most of the top two's performance without the premium price.
Weber Slate's stainless build still earns its price
A 9.5 build quality score reflects full stainless construction that outlasts painted steel bodies outdoors; the tradeoff remains a lower 7.9 value score.