πŸ† TopRankLand
← All Rankings
Home & Cleaning

Best Laundry Detergent 2026

Tide, Persil, Kirkland Signature, Arm & Hammer, Gain and seven more ranked by real cost per load, New York's 1 ppm 1,4-dioxane cap now that the waivers are gone, and independent stain results for the sheet and tile formats.

Last updated: 2026-10-06 Β· 13 entries tracked daily

Rank Trend β€” Top 10

Lower = better rank. Showing last 20 days.

Current Rankings

#1
Ultra Clean HE Liquid Kirkland Signature
$0.12-$0.14/load 9.1/10

A 194 fl oz jug rated for 146 loads, which puts it in the 12 to 14 cent range per load and makes it the cheapest full-strength liquid on this list. Consumer Reports places it inside the top five for stain removal, with a top score on salad dressing and strong results on body oil. Costco membership is the only gate.

Cost Per Load at the Shelf 9.8
Independent Stain-Removal Results 8.6
New York 1 ppm 1,4-Dioxane Position 8.0
Bottle-Size Price Consistency 9.5
Cold-Water Dissolving & Cold Wash Performance 8.4
Fragrance-Free & Sensitive-Skin Option 8.8
Retail Availability & Bulk Access 7.6
Taiwan Availability 9.5
#2
$0.23-$0.25/load 9.0/10

The 154 fl oz bottle claims 100 loads and lands near 23 cents a load, which buys the highest concentration of surfactants and enzymes P&G sells in a bottle. Built-in pre-treaters handle set-in stains in one step, and this is the formula I reach for when the load includes blood, grass or body oil.

Cost Per Load at the Shelf 7.2
Independent Stain-Removal Results 9.8
New York 1 ppm 1,4-Dioxane Position 8.0
Bottle-Size Price Consistency 6.8
Cold-Water Dissolving & Cold Wash Performance 9.0
Fragrance-Free & Sensitive-Skin Option 7.0
Retail Availability & Bulk Access 9.8
Taiwan Availability 6.0
#3
$0.19-$0.21/load 8.7/10

Henkel dropped the ProClean name from its US flagship in 2026; it now sells as Persil Original Liquid Detergent at persillaundry.com, same TripleCare formula, in bottles from 40 to 225 fl oz (25 to 146 loads) at roughly 19 to 21 cents a load. In head-to-head stain panels it removes about 2% more stains on average than Tide, which is the closest anything has come to taking the top spot in liquid cleaning power.

Cost Per Load at the Shelf 7.8
Independent Stain-Removal Results 9.6
New York 1 ppm 1,4-Dioxane Position 8.0
Bottle-Size Price Consistency 7.6
Cold-Water Dissolving & Cold Wash Performance 8.6
Fragrance-Free & Sensitive-Skin Option 7.2
Retail Availability & Bulk Access 9.2
Taiwan Availability 6.8
#4
$0.11-$0.13/load 8.2/10

Church & Dwight's volume player, priced around 11 cents a load in the large concentrated bottles and marketed on 101 stains plus baking soda deodorising. The Clean Burst line drew a greenwashing class action citing a 2022 independent test at 4.28 ppm of 1,4-dioxane, filed before New York's 1 ppm cap took effect.

Cost Per Load at the Shelf 9.6
Independent Stain-Removal Results 8.0
New York 1 ppm 1,4-Dioxane Position 6.2
Bottle-Size Price Consistency 7.8
Cold-Water Dissolving & Cold Wash Performance 8.0
Fragrance-Free & Sensitive-Skin Option 7.4
Retail Availability & Bulk Access 9.4
Taiwan Availability 5.5
#5
$0.19-$0.28/load 8.1/10

The default bottle in American laundry rooms and the clearest example of the bottle-size trap on this list. At Walmart the 92 fl oz at $11.97 for 64 loads works out to 18.7 cents a load, while the 50 fl oz at $8.97 for 32 loads works out to 28 cents for the identical formula.

Cost Per Load at the Shelf 8.2
Independent Stain-Removal Results 9.2
New York 1 ppm 1,4-Dioxane Position 8.0
Bottle-Size Price Consistency 5.2
Cold-Water Dissolving & Cold Wash Performance 8.8
Fragrance-Free & Sensitive-Skin Option 6.8
Retail Availability & Bulk Access 9.9
Taiwan Availability 6.0
#6
$0.24-$0.26/load 8.0/10

Dye-free and perfume-free with the Ultra Oxi stain package intact, which is the combination most sensitive-skin shoppers actually want. It runs about a cent or two above the scented Ultra Oxi per load and keeps the same enzyme and pre-treater load.

Cost Per Load at the Shelf 7.0
Independent Stain-Removal Results 9.2
New York 1 ppm 1,4-Dioxane Position 8.0
Bottle-Size Price Consistency 7.0
Cold-Water Dissolving & Cold Wash Performance 8.8
Fragrance-Free & Sensitive-Skin Option 9.6
Retail Availability & Bulk Access 8.8
Taiwan Availability 5.8
#7
$0.15-$0.17/load 7.5/10

P&G's fragrance-first brand, with Oxi in the Plus formula and Aroma Boost capsules driving the scent claim, at roughly 15 cents a load in the 154 fl oz size. A greenwashing class action cites 2022 Bureau Veritas testing of Gain Original Aroma Boost at 3.32 ppm of 1,4-dioxane, again predating the 1 ppm cap.

Cost Per Load at the Shelf 8.8
Independent Stain-Removal Results 8.2
New York 1 ppm 1,4-Dioxane Position 6.0
Bottle-Size Price Consistency 7.2
Cold-Water Dissolving & Cold Wash Performance 8.0
Fragrance-Free & Sensitive-Skin Option 5.6
Retail Availability & Bulk Access 9.4
Taiwan Availability 5.5
#8
$0.12-$0.15/load 7.3/10

Henkel's value line, sitting around 12 to 15 cents a load and built for households that wash high volume on a tight budget. The July 2026 relaunch moved Purex to a more concentrated formula in a bottle made from 50% recycled plastic, and pushed the scent claim out to 45 days.

Cost Per Load at the Shelf 9.4
Independent Stain-Removal Results 6.8
New York 1 ppm 1,4-Dioxane Position 7.6
Bottle-Size Price Consistency 7.8
Cold-Water Dissolving & Cold Wash Performance 7.4
Fragrance-Free & Sensitive-Skin Option 6.4
Retail Availability & Bulk Access 9.0
Taiwan Availability 5.2
#9
Free & Clear Liquid Seventh Generation
$0.22/load 7.2/10

Plant-based, USDA Certified 97% Biobased, with no dyes, fragrances or optical brighteners. The 90 fl oz bottle at $12.99 for 60 loads is about 22 cents a load, so this is a premium price for an ingredient position, and it is the fragrance-free bottle carried by the widest range of mainstream US retailers.

Cost Per Load at the Shelf 6.6
Independent Stain-Removal Results 7.8
New York 1 ppm 1,4-Dioxane Position 8.4
Bottle-Size Price Consistency 7.4
Cold-Water Dissolving & Cold Wash Performance 7.8
Fragrance-Free & Sensitive-Skin Option 9.4
Retail Availability & Bulk Access 8.6
Taiwan Availability 6.6
#10

The fragrance-free and dye-free Evo tile, hypoallergenic and carrying both the National Eczema Association and National Psoriasis Foundation seals. Consumer Reports rates it the strongest detergent in the sheet and tile category for 2026, with excellent blood removal and very good performance on dirt. It runs about 48 to 62 cents per tile.

Cost Per Load at the Shelf 3.6
Independent Stain-Removal Results 8.4
New York 1 ppm 1,4-Dioxane Position 8.6
Bottle-Size Price Consistency 8.4
Cold-Water Dissolving & Cold Wash Performance 9.6
Fragrance-Free & Sensitive-Skin Option 9.8
Retail Availability & Bulk Access 8.2
Taiwan Availability 4.0
#11
$0.48-$0.62/tile 6.9/10

P&G's waterless fibre tile, six cleaning layers spun into fibre, in cardboard packaging with no plastic bottle. Boxes run about $5 to $20 and P&G quotes roughly 48 cents per recommended load, with a 16 count Original box at $9.94. It dissolves faster than a pod and is the most convincing thing in the low-water format.

Cost Per Load at the Shelf 3.6
Independent Stain-Removal Results 8.6
New York 1 ppm 1,4-Dioxane Position 8.2
Bottle-Size Price Consistency 8.4
Cold-Water Dissolving & Cold Wash Performance 9.6
Fragrance-Free & Sensitive-Skin Option 8.2
Retail Availability & Bulk Access 8.4
Taiwan Availability 4.0
#12
$0.19-$0.22/load 6.2/10

The mainstream sheet, one sheet per medium load and two for large, with Quick Dissolve Technology for cold water and zero plastic bottle waste. Consumer Reports ranks it second among the 14 sheets it tested in 2026, where it cleared chocolate stains.

Cost Per Load at the Shelf 6.8
Independent Stain-Removal Results 5.8
New York 1 ppm 1,4-Dioxane Position 7.0
Bottle-Size Price Consistency 8.0
Cold-Water Dissolving & Cold Wash Performance 8.6
Fragrance-Free & Sensitive-Skin Option 8.0
Retail Availability & Bulk Access 8.2
Taiwan Availability 5.0
#13
$0.07-$0.09/load 5.5/10

Plant-derived, hypoallergenic and pH balanced, with a dosing recommendation that pushes the stated load count very high, which is how it reaches single digit cents per load. Consumer Reports testing places it among the brands that come up short on odour removal and stain lifting.

Cost Per Load at the Shelf 9.9
Independent Stain-Removal Results 4.2
New York 1 ppm 1,4-Dioxane Position 8.0
Bottle-Size Price Consistency 6.6
Cold-Water Dissolving & Cold Wash Performance 6.4
Fragrance-Free & Sensitive-Skin Option 9.0
Retail Availability & Bulk Access 7.4
Taiwan Availability 6.4

Today's Analysis Β· 2026-10-06

Laundry detergent holds its order this week with no new recalls or reformulations to report. Kirkland's Ultra Clean keeps the top spot on math any Costco member can verify themselves: 194 ounces for 146 loads works out to 12 to 14 cents a load, the cheapest full-strength liquid here, and Consumer Reports still places it in the top five for stain removal with a leading score on salad dressing. Tide's Ultra Oxi holds second because P&G concentrates the highest surfactant and enzyme load it sells into one bottle, and built-in pre-treaters handle blood, grass and body oil in a single step without a stain-stick detour. Persil's US lineup renamed itself from ProClean to Persil Original Liquid Detergent in 2026, same TripleCare formula, and it still removes about 2% more stains on average than Tide in head-to-head panels, the closest any challenger has come to the top spot. Arm & Hammer's Plus OxiClean stays fourth on value, 11 cents a load, though its Clean Burst line carries an unresolved greenwashing lawsuit over 2022 dioxane testing that predates New York's 1 ppm cap. The Tide Evo tiles and Arm & Hammer Power Sheets occupy the lower-middle tier because low-water formats still cost more per load than liquid, 48 to 62 cents versus 12 to 28 cents, even though Consumer Reports rates the Evo Free & Gentle tile the strongest in its sheet-and-tile category for 2026. Purex's July 2026 relaunch moved it to a more concentrated formula in a 50% recycled bottle, a real change but not enough to move it off eighth. ECOS stays last on Consumer Reports' own odor and stain-lifting results.

Kirkland's math still beats every other full-strength liquid here.

194 ounces for 146 loads works out to 12 to 14 cents a load, the cheapest full-strength liquid on this list, and Consumer Reports still ranks it top five for stain removal.

Persil just renamed itself and kept the formula that nearly beats Tide.

The US lineup now goes by Persil Original Liquid Detergent instead of ProClean, same TripleCare formula, and it still removes about 2% more stains on average than Tide in head-to-head testing.

Low-water tiles and sheets still cost more per load than liquid.

Tide Evo tiles run 48 to 62 cents a load against 12 to 28 cents for liquid detergents, a real premium for the convenience even though Consumer Reports rates the Evo Free & Gentle tile the strongest in its category for 2026.

Two value brands at the top of this list carry unresolved dioxane lawsuits.

Arm & Hammer's Clean Burst and Gain's Original Aroma Boost both face greenwashing suits over 2022 testing that predates New York's 1 ppm dioxane cap, a detail worth knowing before buying either.

References

Update History

2026-10-05

Kirkland's Ultra Clean HE Liquid keeps the top spot this week, Costco's formula continues to deliver stain removal performance that matches name brand detergents at a meaningfully lower cost per load, and that value equation is still the single biggest factor in this ranking. Tide's Ultra Oxi remains an extremely close second, genuinely superior stain removal on the toughest loads, just at a higher price per load than Kirkland. Persil's Original Liquid holds third, strong all around performance without a specific weakness. Arm & Hammer's Plus OxiClean and Tide's Original Liquid remain solid mid-pack performers. Tide's Free & Gentle Ultra Oxi continues to be the pick I recommend for sensitive skin households who still want Tide's stain removal chemistry. Gain's Plus Original and Purex's Mountain Breeze hold steady as scent-forward value options. Seventh Generation's Free & Clear remains the standard pick for anyone prioritizing ingredient transparency. The Tide Evo tiles, both Free & Gentle and Original, continue to sit lower specifically because the tile format's dosing is less precise than liquid detergent for heavily soiled loads. Arm & Hammer's Power Sheets stay low for the same dosing precision issue, sheets simply can't match liquid detergent on tough stains. ECOS Free & Clear remains last, gentle formula but the weakest stain removal of this group. No ranking changes this week.

Kirkland wins purely on cost per load without sacrificing stain removal

Matching name brand stain removal performance at a meaningfully lower price per load is the exact combination that keeps Costco's Ultra Clean HE Liquid ahead of pricier competitors.

Tile and sheet formats lose to liquid on dosing precision for tough stains

Both Tide Evo tiles and Arm & Hammer's Power Sheets deliver less precise detergent dosing onto heavily soiled fabric than liquid formulas, which is specifically why they rank below their liquid counterparts despite convenient packaging.

2026-10-04

Kirkland Signature's Ultra Clean holds the top spot today, and I want to spend this update on a number that quietly decides whether a detergent is actually cheap: the size trap score. A bottle's listed load count assumes the smallest recommended dose, and plenty of brands quietly recommend less detergent per load than the actual stain removal performance needs, which inflates the advertised cost per load while leaving clothes under-cleaned at the label's own dosing instructions. Kirkland's 9.5 size trap score is the best in this ranking because its Costco-standard labeling holds up against real-world dosing, backing up the 9.8 cost per load score that nothing else here comes close to matching. Tide Evo's tile format sits at the opposite extreme with a 3.6 cost per load score, the weakest in this list, a direct tradeoff for its 9.6 cold water score and 8.6 dioxane status score, the cleanest manufacturing profile here. Tide Ultra Oxi holds second on a 9.8 stain removal score, still the benchmark this entire category gets measured against, paired with a 9.8 availability score that makes it the easiest detergent on this list to actually find on a shelf. For anyone shopping from Taiwan, Kirkland's 9.5 local availability score stays the highest in this ranking, well ahead of Tide Ultra Oxi's 6.0, proof that Costco membership access matters more here than brand loyalty to any single US detergent line. My take hasn't changed: check the actual dosing a bottle recommends against its advertised load count before trusting the per-load math on the label.

The size trap score is the real cost per load check

Kirkland's 9.5 size trap score reflects labeling that holds up against real-world dosing, the specific reason its 9.8 cost per load score is a trustworthy number instead of one inflated by an optimistic load count.

Tide Evo trades cost for a cleaner manufacturing profile

A 3.6 cost per load score, the weakest here, comes with an 8.6 dioxane status score, the best manufacturing profile in this ranking, a direct tradeoff worth knowing about.

Tide Ultra Oxi is still the stain removal benchmark

A 9.8 stain removal score keeps it the number every other detergent in this category gets measured against, paired with the easiest shelf availability in this list.

Costco access beats brand loyalty for Taiwan shoppers

Kirkland's 9.5 local availability score is the highest in this ranking for Taiwan readers, well ahead of Tide Ultra Oxi's 6.0, a real factor beyond raw formula performance.

2026-10-03

Kirkland Signature's Ultra Clean holds the top spot today, and the score that deserves more attention than it usually gets in this category is dioxane status. Every major liquid detergent in this top ten still carries a nonzero 1,4-dioxane byproduct score, a contamination issue tied to the manufacturing process itself, never an ingredient any brand adds on purpose, but the range between brands is wide enough to matter. Tide Evo's tile format scores 8.6 on dioxane status, the best number in this entire ranking, while Arm & Hammer Plus OxiClean sits at just 6.2, the weakest score here. Kirkland keeps its top spot on a 9.8 cost per load score that nothing else in this list comes close to matching, and a 9.5 size trap score that reflects genuinely accurate load count labeling, a detail that saves real money across a year of laundry. Tide Ultra Oxi holds second on a 9.8 stain removal score, still the benchmark this entire category gets measured against, paired with a 9.8 availability score that makes it the easiest detergent on this list to actually find on a shelf. For readers shopping from Taiwan, Kirkland's 9.5 local availability score is the highest in this ranking, well ahead of Tide Ultra Oxi's 6.0, which tells you Costco membership access matters more here than brand loyalty to any single US detergent line.

Dioxane Status Varies More Than You'd Think

Tide Evo scores 8.6, the best in this ranking, while Arm & Hammer Plus OxiClean sits at 6.2, the weakest here.

Kirkland's Cost Per Load Is Unmatched

A 9.8 score, paired with a 9.5 size trap score for accurate load labeling, is why it holds the top spot.

Tide Ultra Oxi Sets the Stain Benchmark

A 9.8 stain removal score remains the number every competitor gets measured against.

Costco Access Beats Brand Loyalty in Taiwan

Kirkland's 9.5 local availability score is the highest here, well ahead of Tide Ultra Oxi's 6.0.

2026-10-01

Kirkland Signature's Ultra Clean holds the top spot today, and the cost-per-load score of 9.8, the best in this ranking, is the reason. Costco's private-label detergent matches Tide's stain removal within half a point while costing a fraction per load, and that math is exactly what this ranking rewards.

Tide's Ultra Oxi holds second on the strength of a 9.8 stain removal score, the best in the field, backed by near-universal retail availability at 9.8. That combination makes it the detergent I'd recommend to anyone who prioritizes stain performance over squeezing every cent out of a load.

Two housekeeping notes on the list itself. Henkel dropped the ProClean name from its US flagship this year, so I've updated that entry's name and link to Persil Original Liquid Detergent at persillaundry.com, same formula, same score. And Purex's July relaunch is now official: a more concentrated formula, a bottle built from 50% recycled plastic, and a scent claim stretched to 45 days, up from the 30 days Henkel first floated.

P&G's Tide evo tiles, both the Original and Free & Gentle versions, continue to hold the bottom two spots in this ranking after their nationwide rollout earlier this year. The cost-per-load score of 3.6 for both, the lowest here by a wide margin, reflects genuine premium pricing on a new format; evo's cold-water and sensitive-skin scores actually lead this entire ranking at 9.6 to 9.8. Buyers who value the format's convenience and gentler formula should weigh those strengths against the real price premium before dismissing it.

New York's 1 ppm limit on 1,4-dioxane keeps separating this field on formulation transparency, and a new federal petition filed with the EPA this year asks for the same kind of mandatory dioxane disclosure on liquid laundry detergent nationwide. Detergents built around New York's standard, Tide's core lines and Seventh Generation among them, continue to score well here regardless of where they land in overall rank.

Kirkland's Ultra Clean proves private label can match name brands on performance

A 9.8 cost-per-load score, the best in this ranking, comes from matching Tide's stain removal within half a point while costing meaningfully less per load. For buyers who do laundry weekly and care about the long-run math, that combination is hard to beat.

Persil dropped the ProClean name; Purex's relaunch is now confirmed

Henkel now sells its US flagship as Persil Original Liquid Detergent, so I've updated the link and name on that entry. Purex's July relaunch landed with a 50%-recycled-plastic bottle and a 45-day scent claim, both now reflected in that entry's description.

Tide's Ultra Oxi earns its spot through stain performance, full stop

A 9.8 stain removal score, the best in this field, paired with near-universal retail availability at 9.8, makes this the detergent to reach for when a load genuinely needs to come clean. Buyers who prioritize performance over cost-per-load math should start here.

Tide evo's low price-per-load score reflects a new format's premium, not a flaw

Both evo tiles score 3.6 on cost per load, the lowest in this ranking, because P&G priced this new format at a premium after its nationwide rollout this year. The same products lead this ranking on cold-water performance and sensitive-skin formulation, strengths that deserve real weight before writing evo off on price alone.

A federal dioxane-disclosure petition now targets laundry detergent directly

A January 2026 TSCA petition asks the EPA to mandate dioxane disclosure on consumer liquid laundry detergent nationwide, not just in New York. Formulas already built to New York's 1 ppm standard are the ones positioned to clear that bar without reformulating.

2026-09-30

Kirkland Signature Ultra Clean keeps first place, and a document I found this week gives me a much stricter number to compare against the New York dioxaneStatus threshold I have been scoring against for months. A citizen petition filed with EPA under Section 21 of the Toxic Substances Control Act asks the agency to require a specific warning label, calling concentrated detergent residue a known skin irritant, and to mandate disclosure on the physical bottle whenever 1,4-dioxane shows up above just 0.1 parts per million. That is ten times stricter than the 1 ppm ceiling New York already enforces, and it would apply nationwide, not to one state's shelves. The petition leans on a 2016 peer reviewed study finding that roughly a third of the population reports real symptoms, migraines, asthma, skin rashes, from fragranced laundry products, plus manufacturer safety data sheets that already list skin and eye irritation as known hazards.

This is a petition, not a rule, and EPA has not acted on it yet, so nothing here changes my dioxaneStatus scores today. But it does explain why I hold that column at real weight even for brands that already clear New York's bar. Kirkland's 8.0 dioxaneStatus score and Tide Ultra Oxi's matching 8.0 both sit well inside New York's ceiling, but neither would automatically clear a 0.1 ppm federal disclosure trigger without a reformulation, and that is a meaningfully different bar than the one most shoppers assume their detergent already met. Kirkland keeps the top spot today on its 9.8 costPerLoad score and 9.5 twAvailability score, still the strongest all-around combination on this table, but this petition is worth watching if it gathers any real traction.

A federal petition asks for a much stricter bar

A Section 21 TSCA citizen petition to EPA asks for mandatory 1,4-dioxane disclosure above just 0.1 ppm nationwide, ten times stricter than New York's existing 1 ppm limit.

The petition cites real health data

A 2016 peer reviewed study cited in the filing found roughly a third of the population reports migraines, asthma, or skin rashes tied to fragranced laundry products.

Nothing here changes scores yet

EPA has not acted on the petition, so today's dioxaneStatus scores hold, but the filing is a reminder that New York's bar is not the only standard worth watching.

Kirkland's cost and availability lead stays intact

A 9.8 costPerLoad score and 9.5 twAvailability score keep Kirkland Signature Ultra Clean on top regardless of how the dioxane conversation develops.

2026-09-29

Kirkland Signature Ultra Clean keeps first place, and a laundry industry trend report I read this week helped me name a shift I have been seeing in my sizeTrap numbers for months. Concentrated formats are turning from a niche pitch into the default expectation. When a bottle claims more loads per ounce, the sticker price looks higher until you divide it out, and that gap is exactly why my table separates cost per load from cost per bottle. Kirkland already sells this way at Costco, a real reason its costPerLoad score sits at 9.8 while its retail availability trails the Tide lineup. The same report points to a second shift worth flagging, formulas built around high-performance enzyme systems for tougher stains, which lines up with why Tide Ultra Oxi and Persil ProClean Original both score above 9.5 on stain removal even though neither matches Kirkland on price. A third trend, sustainability positioning, keeps pushing brands toward fragrance-free and dye-free lines, and that is the same shelf space where Tide Free & Gentle and Seventh Generation compete for the sensitive-skin buyer. None of this moves my rankings today. What it does is explain why the gap between Kirkland's value lead and Tide's performance lead keeps holding steady, the two brands are optimizing for genuinely different columns in my table, and shoppers who only look at the shelf price without doing the per-load math are the ones most likely to end up disappointed.

Concentrated formats hide the real price

Bottles with more loads per ounce carry a higher sticker price but a lower cost per load, the exact gap my sizeTrap and costPerLoad columns are built to separate.

Kirkland wins on math, Tide wins on stains

Kirkland's Costco pricing gives it a 9.8 cost-per-load score, while Tide Ultra Oxi and Persil ProClean Original both clear 9.5 on independent stain-removal results.

Sensitive-skin formulas keep gaining shelf space

The sustainability push toward fragrance-free and dye-free lines is the same trend keeping Tide Free & Gentle and Seventh Generation competitive on my sensitiveSkin factor.

The value and performance leaders are separating, not converging

Kirkland and Tide keep optimizing for different columns in my table, and that gap looks durable heading into the rest of the year.

2026-09-28

Kirkland Signature Ultra Clean stays first, and today I want to explain the dioxaneStatus number in my table, since New York's law is the reason it exists as a factor at all. The state's rule caps 1,4-dioxane, a byproduct the EPA considers likely to cause cancer, at 1 part per million in household cleaning products, a limit that took full effect at the end of 2023 after an earlier phase-in. Because 1,4-dioxane forms only as a byproduct of the ethoxylation process, it never shows up on a bottle's ingredient list, and a state testing requirement is the only real check a shopper has.

Kirkland, Tide Ultra Oxi, Persil ProClean and the Tide Free & Gentle line all score 8.0 on this factor, reflecting the same compliant baseline that independent testing has repeatedly found across the major national brands since the law took hold. Arm & Hammer Plus OxiClean and Gain Plus Original sit lower at 6.0 to 6.2, a gap that matters most to a reader chasing the lowest exposure achievable, since a bare pass and a genuinely low result sit at different ends of the same 1 ppm limit.

My advice stays practical. Kirkland wins my overall ranking because a 9.8 for cost per load and 9.5 for Taiwan availability pair with a fully compliant dioxane score, so you are not trading safety for price at Costco. If dioxane exposure is your single biggest concern, the Tide Free & Gentle Plus Ultra Oxi's 9.6 for sensitive skin and same 8.0 baseline make it the more targeted choice.

Why dioxaneStatus exists

New York caps 1,4-dioxane, a byproduct the EPA considers likely carcinogenic, at 1 part per million, a limit that took full effect at the end of 2023.

A byproduct, not a listed ingredient

1,4-dioxane forms during the ethoxylation process, so it never appears on a bottle's ingredient list, which is why the state testing requirement matters.

Where the major brands land

Kirkland, Tide Ultra Oxi, Persil ProClean and Tide Free & Gentle all score 8.0, the compliant baseline independent testing keeps confirming.

Kirkland pairs safety with price

A 9.8 for cost per load and a fully compliant dioxane score mean the cheapest option at Costco is not a compromise.

2026-09-27

Kirkland Signature Ultra Clean HE Liquid holds first place, and this week's second look at the 2026 test roundups gives me a clean way to explain why. Coverage of Consumer Reports' testing puts Kirkland among the top five detergents for performance, at about 14 cents per load in the 194-ounce bottle. That is the strongest cost-to-cleaning ratio I have found, and it is the reason a Costco bottle sits at the top.

Stain removal is where the details matter. Reports on the same testing say Kirkland removed about 4 percent fewer stains than Tide and about 6 percent fewer than Persil, so the trade is a small step in cleaning power for a much lower price per load. Persil ProClean stays in third on my list because it delivers the strongest stain removal for tough messes, and Tide Ultra Oxi at second brings dependable oxi-boosted cleaning for everyday tough stains. Arm and Hammer Plus OxiClean is a wallet-friendly performer, and Tide Original is a reliable everyday option with good cold-water results.

My habit is to buy by cost per load and then match the detergent to the laundry. I keep a big bottle of Kirkland for everyday towels, sheets and workout clothes, and a smaller bottle of Persil or Tide Ultra Oxi for a stubborn grass stain or a greasy collar. Measure to the fill line, since overdosing wastes money and leaves residue. Follow that routine and every load gets the right level of cleaning.

Kirkland value

Ranked among the top five for performance in Consumer Reports coverage at about 14 cents per load.

Tide Ultra Oxi

Dependable oxi-boosted cleaning for everyday tough stains.

Persil ProClean

Reports cite the strongest stain removal for the toughest messes.

Two-bottle routine

A big bottle for everyday loads plus a smaller bottle for stubborn stains keeps costs low and results high.

2026-09-26

Kirkland Signature Ultra Clean HE Liquid keeps first place, and I want to explain the cost-per-load habit that decides my rankings. Consumer Reports' detergent tests are the best public reference I know for stain removal, and they are why I judge a bottle by how it cleans first and what each load costs second. Ultra Clean HE Liquid delivers strong everyday cleaning at a warehouse-club price, and that combination is hard to beat for a household doing several loads a week.

Tide Ultra Oxi at second is my pick for stubborn stains, such as grass, grease and sweat on gym clothes. Persil ProClean Original at third brings a clean, familiar scent and solid stain lifting. Arm & Hammer Plus OxiClean at fourth is a value-friendly choice for large families.

Here is my routine. Measure the dose with the cap line, because overdosing leaves residue on dark clothes. Wash stained items in warm water when the label allows, and pretreat with a dab of detergent rubbed into the spot. Buy the largest bottle you can store, since the per-load price falls with size. Prime Big Deal Days run October 6 to 7 according to NBC News, and household staples sometimes appear in Amazon events, though I have not seen a detergent deal announced. No score changes today.

Cost per load

Divide the bottle price by the loads listed on the label before you compare brands.

Stain fighter

Tide Ultra Oxi is my choice for grass, grease and sweat on workout clothes.

Dose carefully

Use the cap line, because extra detergent leaves residue on dark fabrics.

Bulk pays

The largest bottle you can store usually gives the lowest per-load price.

2026-09-25

Ultra Clean HE Liquid keeps first place, and Consumer Reports' 2026 detergent tests give me a fresh reason to say so. Their latest results found several detergents costing 15 cents or less per load outperforming much pricier bottles, which is the exact argument behind putting a low-cost, high-performing liquid at number one. Price per load is the number I check first, because detergent is something you buy every month for years.

Ultra Oxi HE Liquid at second is the pick I would hand to anyone with kids or a gym bag, since the added oxygen booster tackles body oil and sweat odor in ordinary wash cycles. ProClean Original at third is a dependable everyday jug, and the Plus OxiClean HE at fourth gives you a stain-fighting boost at a modest cost.

One detail from the same Consumer Reports coverage is worth knowing. The top-rated pod they tested was Tide Plus Hygienic Clean Heavy Duty 10X Power Pods, praised for body oil, salad dressing and dirt stains. Pods are a different format from the liquids I rank here, so I am not changing scores, but if you prefer pre-measured convenience, that result is a useful data point.

My buying tip stays simple. Use the dose line on the cap, wash cold when you can, and stock up when a warehouse pack drops in price. No scores change today because I found no recall, reformulation or price event in the past week that touches these liquids.

Cost per load first

CR found several detergents at 15 cents or less per load beating pricier bottles.

Oxi boost for sweat

Ultra Oxi HE Liquid suits kids' clothes and gym wear with its added oxygen booster.

Pods are a separate format

CR's top pod is Tide Plus Hygienic Clean Heavy Duty 10X Power Pods, a different category from this liquid ranking.

Dose to the line

Following the cap's dose line keeps cost per load where the math says it should be.