2026-09-17
The ranking holds, and Kirkland Signature Ultra Clean keeps first at 9.1. Last week I gave you the cost per load arithmetic. This week I want to talk about water temperature, because it is the setting that saves you the most money and the one P&G is openly trying to change.
P&G has set a goal for 75% of laundry loads to be washed in cold water by 2030, and it reported reaching 65% in 2024. The reason is energy. Most of the electricity a hot wash uses goes into heating the water, so switching a load to cold cuts that load's energy bill sharply while the washer's motor use stays the same.
Every detergent in my top five cleans well in cold water. Kirkland Ultra Clean and Tide Ultra Oxi both use enzyme blends that work at low temperatures, which is exactly why they score so highly on grass, sebum and food stains. Persil ProClean at third is strong on oily soils. I wash nearly everything cold now and keep warm water for heavily soiled towels and bedding.
Tide evo, at tenth and eleventh, is the product built around this idea. It is a waterless fibre tile with six cleaning layers designed to activate in cold water, sold in a curbside recyclable cardboard box. Retail analysts estimate liquid detergent at about 20 cents a load, pods at about 31 cents and the tiles at about 48 cents. That price is why evo sits where it does, and its convenience and plastic free packaging are why it earns a spot at all. For someone who carries laundry to a shared machine, a tile you drop in the drum is genuinely pleasant to use.
My recommendation: buy a large jug of Kirkland or Tide Ultra Oxi, dose to the line, and set the dial to cold.
P&G is pushing cold washing
P&G targets 75% of loads in cold water by 2030 and reported 65% in 2024.
Cold saves the most energy
Most of a hot wash's electricity goes into heating water, so cold loads cut energy use sharply.
Top five clean well cold
Kirkland Ultra Clean, at 9.1, and Tide Ultra Oxi rely on enzymes that work at low temperatures.
Tide evo trades cost for convenience
Analysts put tiles near 48 cents a load, against about 20 cents for liquid, with plastic free packaging in return.