πŸ† TopRankLand
← All Rankings
Home & Cleaning

Best Laundry Detergent 2026

Tide, Persil, Kirkland Signature, Arm & Hammer, Gain and seven more ranked by real cost per load, New York's 1 ppm 1,4-dioxane cap now that the waivers are gone, and independent stain results for the sheet and tile formats.

Last updated: 2026-09-18 Β· 13 entries tracked daily

Rank Trend β€” Top 10

Lower = better rank. Showing last 6 days.

Current Rankings

#1
Ultra Clean HE Liquid Kirkland Signature
$0.12-$0.14/load 9.1/10

A 194 fl oz jug rated for 146 loads, which puts it in the 12 to 14 cent range per load and makes it the cheapest full-strength liquid on this list. Consumer Reports places it inside the top five for stain removal, with a top score on salad dressing and strong results on body oil. Costco membership is the only gate.

Cost Per Load at the Shelf 9.8
Independent Stain-Removal Results 8.6
New York 1 ppm 1,4-Dioxane Position 8.0
Bottle-Size Price Consistency 9.5
Cold-Water Dissolving & Cold Wash Performance 8.4
Fragrance-Free & Sensitive-Skin Option 8.8
Retail Availability & Bulk Access 7.6
Taiwan Availability 9.5
#2
$0.23-$0.25/load 9.0/10

The 154 fl oz bottle claims 100 loads and lands near 23 cents a load, which buys the highest concentration of surfactants and enzymes P&G sells in a bottle. Built-in pre-treaters handle set-in stains in one step, and this is the formula I reach for when the load includes blood, grass or body oil.

Cost Per Load at the Shelf 7.2
Independent Stain-Removal Results 9.8
New York 1 ppm 1,4-Dioxane Position 8.0
Bottle-Size Price Consistency 6.8
Cold-Water Dissolving & Cold Wash Performance 9.0
Fragrance-Free & Sensitive-Skin Option 7.0
Retail Availability & Bulk Access 9.8
Taiwan Availability 6.0
#3
$0.19-$0.21/load 8.7/10

Henkel's US flagship, sold in a 150 fl oz bottle rated for 96 loads at roughly 19 to 21 cents a load. In head-to-head stain panels it removes about 2% more stains on average than Tide, which is the closest anything has come to taking the top spot in liquid cleaning power.

Cost Per Load at the Shelf 7.8
Independent Stain-Removal Results 9.6
New York 1 ppm 1,4-Dioxane Position 8.0
Bottle-Size Price Consistency 7.6
Cold-Water Dissolving & Cold Wash Performance 8.6
Fragrance-Free & Sensitive-Skin Option 7.2
Retail Availability & Bulk Access 9.2
Taiwan Availability 6.8
#4
$0.11-$0.13/load 8.2/10

Church & Dwight's volume player, priced around 11 cents a load in the large concentrated bottles and marketed on 101 stains plus baking soda deodorising. The Clean Burst line drew a greenwashing class action citing a 2022 independent test at 4.28 ppm of 1,4-dioxane, filed before New York's 1 ppm cap took effect.

Cost Per Load at the Shelf 9.6
Independent Stain-Removal Results 8.0
New York 1 ppm 1,4-Dioxane Position 6.2
Bottle-Size Price Consistency 7.8
Cold-Water Dissolving & Cold Wash Performance 8.0
Fragrance-Free & Sensitive-Skin Option 7.4
Retail Availability & Bulk Access 9.4
Taiwan Availability 5.5
#5
$0.19-$0.28/load 8.1/10

The default bottle in American laundry rooms and the clearest example of the bottle-size trap on this list. At Walmart the 92 fl oz at $11.97 for 64 loads works out to 18.7 cents a load, while the 50 fl oz at $8.97 for 32 loads works out to 28 cents for the identical formula.

Cost Per Load at the Shelf 8.2
Independent Stain-Removal Results 9.2
New York 1 ppm 1,4-Dioxane Position 8.0
Bottle-Size Price Consistency 5.2
Cold-Water Dissolving & Cold Wash Performance 8.8
Fragrance-Free & Sensitive-Skin Option 6.8
Retail Availability & Bulk Access 9.9
Taiwan Availability 6.0
#6
$0.24-$0.26/load 8.0/10

Dye-free and perfume-free with the Ultra Oxi stain package intact, which is the combination most sensitive-skin shoppers actually want. It runs about a cent or two above the scented Ultra Oxi per load and keeps the same enzyme and pre-treater load.

Cost Per Load at the Shelf 7.0
Independent Stain-Removal Results 9.2
New York 1 ppm 1,4-Dioxane Position 8.0
Bottle-Size Price Consistency 7.0
Cold-Water Dissolving & Cold Wash Performance 8.8
Fragrance-Free & Sensitive-Skin Option 9.6
Retail Availability & Bulk Access 8.8
Taiwan Availability 5.8
#7
$0.15-$0.17/load 7.5/10

P&G's fragrance-first brand, with Oxi in the Plus formula and Aroma Boost capsules driving the scent claim, at roughly 15 cents a load in the 154 fl oz size. A greenwashing class action cites 2022 Bureau Veritas testing of Gain Original Aroma Boost at 3.32 ppm of 1,4-dioxane, again predating the 1 ppm cap.

Cost Per Load at the Shelf 8.8
Independent Stain-Removal Results 8.2
New York 1 ppm 1,4-Dioxane Position 6.0
Bottle-Size Price Consistency 7.2
Cold-Water Dissolving & Cold Wash Performance 8.0
Fragrance-Free & Sensitive-Skin Option 5.6
Retail Availability & Bulk Access 9.4
Taiwan Availability 5.5
#8
$0.12-$0.15/load 7.3/10

Henkel's value line, sitting around 12 to 15 cents a load and built for households that wash high volume on a tight budget. Henkel relaunched the line in 2026 on a more concentrated formula in packaging using recycled resin, and the scent claim runs to 30 days.

Cost Per Load at the Shelf 9.4
Independent Stain-Removal Results 6.8
New York 1 ppm 1,4-Dioxane Position 7.6
Bottle-Size Price Consistency 7.8
Cold-Water Dissolving & Cold Wash Performance 7.4
Fragrance-Free & Sensitive-Skin Option 6.4
Retail Availability & Bulk Access 9.0
Taiwan Availability 5.2
#9
Free & Clear Liquid Seventh Generation
$0.22/load 7.2/10

Plant-based, USDA Certified 97% Biobased, with no dyes, fragrances or optical brighteners. The 90 fl oz bottle at $12.99 for 60 loads is about 22 cents a load, so this is a premium price for an ingredient position, and it is the fragrance-free bottle carried by the widest range of mainstream US retailers.

Cost Per Load at the Shelf 6.6
Independent Stain-Removal Results 7.8
New York 1 ppm 1,4-Dioxane Position 8.4
Bottle-Size Price Consistency 7.4
Cold-Water Dissolving & Cold Wash Performance 7.8
Fragrance-Free & Sensitive-Skin Option 9.4
Retail Availability & Bulk Access 8.6
Taiwan Availability 6.6
#10

The fragrance-free and dye-free Evo tile, hypoallergenic and carrying both the National Eczema Association and National Psoriasis Foundation seals. Consumer Reports rates it the strongest detergent in the sheet and tile category for 2026, with excellent blood removal and very good performance on dirt. It runs about 48 to 62 cents per tile.

Cost Per Load at the Shelf 3.6
Independent Stain-Removal Results 8.4
New York 1 ppm 1,4-Dioxane Position 8.6
Bottle-Size Price Consistency 8.4
Cold-Water Dissolving & Cold Wash Performance 9.6
Fragrance-Free & Sensitive-Skin Option 9.8
Retail Availability & Bulk Access 8.2
Taiwan Availability 4.0
#11
$0.48-$0.62/tile 6.9/10

P&G's waterless fibre tile, six cleaning layers spun into fibre, in cardboard packaging with no plastic bottle. Boxes run about $5 to $20 and P&G quotes roughly 48 cents per recommended load, with a 16 count Original box at $9.94. It dissolves faster than a pod and is the most convincing thing in the low-water format.

Cost Per Load at the Shelf 3.6
Independent Stain-Removal Results 8.6
New York 1 ppm 1,4-Dioxane Position 8.2
Bottle-Size Price Consistency 8.4
Cold-Water Dissolving & Cold Wash Performance 9.6
Fragrance-Free & Sensitive-Skin Option 8.2
Retail Availability & Bulk Access 8.4
Taiwan Availability 4.0
#12
$0.19-$0.22/load 6.2/10

The mainstream sheet, one sheet per medium load and two for large, with Quick Dissolve Technology for cold water and zero plastic bottle waste. Consumer Reports ranks it second among the 14 sheets it tested in 2026, where it cleared chocolate stains.

Cost Per Load at the Shelf 6.8
Independent Stain-Removal Results 5.8
New York 1 ppm 1,4-Dioxane Position 7.0
Bottle-Size Price Consistency 8.0
Cold-Water Dissolving & Cold Wash Performance 8.6
Fragrance-Free & Sensitive-Skin Option 8.0
Retail Availability & Bulk Access 8.2
Taiwan Availability 5.0
#13
$0.07-$0.09/load 5.5/10

Plant-derived, hypoallergenic and pH balanced, with a dosing recommendation that pushes the stated load count very high, which is how it reaches single digit cents per load. Consumer Reports testing places it among the brands that come up short on odour removal and stain lifting.

Cost Per Load at the Shelf 9.9
Independent Stain-Removal Results 4.2
New York 1 ppm 1,4-Dioxane Position 8.0
Bottle-Size Price Consistency 6.6
Cold-Water Dissolving & Cold Wash Performance 6.4
Fragrance-Free & Sensitive-Skin Option 9.0
Retail Availability & Bulk Access 7.4
Taiwan Availability 6.4

Today's Analysis Β· 2026-09-18

The ranking holds, and Kirkland Signature Ultra Clean keeps first at 9.1. Last week I explained the cold water savings. This week I want to open the bottle, because a 2026 R&D review shows where detergent chemistry is heading, and it supports the enzyme-rich formulas at the top of my list.

GreyB's analysis of 2026 detergent innovation highlights four shifts. Enzyme makers are tuning their systems for lower temperatures. P&G is reported to be building a low-pH detergent platform that would change which enzymes can survive in the bottle. Odour control is moving from masking smells with fragrance to breaking down the bacterial biofilm that builds up in athletic wear. And formulators are gradually replacing traditional chelators with citrate based systems to meet clean-label demand.

For shoppers, the lesson is simple. Enzymes are what remove protein and starch stains in cold water, and the detergents that lead my ranking are full of them. Tide Ultra Oxi at second, 9.0, earns a 9.8 stain removal score, the best on my list, and a 9.0 cold water score. Kirkland Ultra Clean takes first by matching most of that cleaning with a 9.8 cost per load score, which matters over the few hundred loads a family runs each year.

The biofilm point matters for anyone who owns leggings or running shirts. Synthetic fabrics hold odour, and a fragrance boost fades while the bacteria stay. I wash gym clothes inside out on a cold cycle with a full dose of an enzyme detergent, and they come out neutral.

My advice: pick an enzyme liquid, dose by the line on the cap, and put the savings toward a good washer. Consumer Reports' testing remains the best independent source on stain performance.

Kirkland Ultra Clean keeps first at 9.1

Strong cleaning plus a 9.8 cost per load score makes it the best value for families.

Enzymes are being tuned for cold water

GreyB's 2026 review shows enzyme systems optimised for low temperatures, and a reported P&G low-pH platform.

Tide Ultra Oxi leads stain removal at 9.8

Second overall at 9.0, it is the strongest cleaner on my list.

Target biofilm in gym clothes

Odour control is moving toward breaking down bacterial biofilm. Wash activewear inside out with a full enzyme dose.

References

Update History

2026-09-17

The ranking holds, and Kirkland Signature Ultra Clean keeps first at 9.1. Last week I gave you the cost per load arithmetic. This week I want to talk about water temperature, because it is the setting that saves you the most money and the one P&G is openly trying to change.

P&G has set a goal for 75% of laundry loads to be washed in cold water by 2030, and it reported reaching 65% in 2024. The reason is energy. Most of the electricity a hot wash uses goes into heating the water, so switching a load to cold cuts that load's energy bill sharply while the washer's motor use stays the same.

Every detergent in my top five cleans well in cold water. Kirkland Ultra Clean and Tide Ultra Oxi both use enzyme blends that work at low temperatures, which is exactly why they score so highly on grass, sebum and food stains. Persil ProClean at third is strong on oily soils. I wash nearly everything cold now and keep warm water for heavily soiled towels and bedding.

Tide evo, at tenth and eleventh, is the product built around this idea. It is a waterless fibre tile with six cleaning layers designed to activate in cold water, sold in a curbside recyclable cardboard box. Retail analysts estimate liquid detergent at about 20 cents a load, pods at about 31 cents and the tiles at about 48 cents. That price is why evo sits where it does, and its convenience and plastic free packaging are why it earns a spot at all. For someone who carries laundry to a shared machine, a tile you drop in the drum is genuinely pleasant to use.

My recommendation: buy a large jug of Kirkland or Tide Ultra Oxi, dose to the line, and set the dial to cold.

P&G is pushing cold washing

P&G targets 75% of loads in cold water by 2030 and reported 65% in 2024.

Cold saves the most energy

Most of a hot wash's electricity goes into heating water, so cold loads cut energy use sharply.

Top five clean well cold

Kirkland Ultra Clean, at 9.1, and Tide Ultra Oxi rely on enzymes that work at low temperatures.

Tide evo trades cost for convenience

Analysts put tiles near 48 cents a load, against about 20 cents for liquid, with plastic free packaging in return.

2026-09-16

The ranking holds, and Kirkland Signature Ultra Clean keeps first at 9.1. Today I want to hand you the arithmetic to use during the next sale, because detergent is the category where a big discount sticker most often hides a worse deal.

Amazon confirmed on 15 September that Prime Big Deal Days run 6 and 7 October, with early deals already posted. Household staples get heavy promotion in that window, and detergent listings are usually sorted by bottle price, which tells you very little.

Do this instead. Divide the shelf price by the load count printed on the front, and write the answer in cents per load on your phone. Kirkland Ultra Clean is 194 fluid ounces rated for 146 loads, which lands between 12 and 14 cents. Tide Ultra Oxi in second sits near 25 to 30 cents in its larger jugs and climbs above 40 in the small ones. The same brand can cost double per load depending on which bottle you grab, and the biggest bottle is only sometimes the cheapest. I have watched mid size jugs beat the jumbo several times this year.

Two more habits for a bulk buy. Store liquid detergent somewhere that stays between 50 and 80 degrees Fahrenheit, because a cold garage thickens it and a hot one separates it. Enzymes also lose activity over about a year, so buy the amount you will actually use in twelve months.

If there is sensitive skin at home, Tide Free and Gentle Plus Ultra Oxi is my pick. It carries the National Eczema Association seal and keeps the oxi stain performance.

One addition today. Tide evo Free & Gentle joins at tenth with 7.1, and it is the tile I would actually buy in that format. Consumer Reports rates it the strongest detergent in the sheet and tile category for 2026, rating it excellent on blood and very good on dirt, and it carries both the National Eczema Association and National Psoriasis Foundation seals. Cost per tile still lands near 48 to 62 cents, which is why it sits where it does on my list. Buy it for the skin certification and the cold-water dissolving, and keep a liquid for heavy stain days.

Kirkland keeps first at 9.1

194 fluid ounces rated for 146 loads, which works out at 12 to 14 cents per load with solid independent stain results.

Write down cents per load

Divide shelf price by the load count on the front. That single number settles almost every detergent decision.

6 and 7 October is the stock up window

Amazon confirmed Prime Big Deal Days and household staples get heavy promotion that week.

Buy twelve months at most

Enzymes lose activity over about a year, and storage between 50 and 80 Fahrenheit keeps the liquid mixed.

Tide evo Free & Gentle is the tile worth buying

It enters at tenth with 7.1 and scores 9.8 on sensitive skin, the highest mark in my table, with both the National Eczema Association and National Psoriasis Foundation seals behind it. Consumer Reports puts it at the top of the sheet and tile category for 2026. At roughly 48 to 62 cents per tile it earns its place on performance and skin safety.

2026-09-15

The ranking holds, and Kirkland Signature Ultra Clean keeps first at 9.1. It is Costco's HE liquid in a 194 fl oz jug rated for 146 loads, landing between 12 and 14 cents per load. Cost per load follows you through every wash of the year, Kirkland leads that column, and its independent stain results are solid.

Autumn is my focus this week, because tap water cools as the season turns. RefillWatch's 2026 guide cautions that powders dissolve less reliably below 60 degrees Fahrenheit, and that is exactly when liquid detergent earns its place. A concentrated liquid disperses fully in a cold wash, so the cleaning agents get to work right away. That is why I weight cold water performance heavily and keep liquids at the top.

Tide Ultra Oxi holds second at 9.0. Its enzyme and oxygen booster formula justifies roughly 23 cents a load on grass, food and the mud that comes with school sports season. Persil ProClean Original stays third at 8.7 at about 20 cents, the strongest mainstream option for heavy loads. For sensitive skin, Tide Free & Gentle Plus Ultra Oxi at 8.0 keeps the Ultra Oxi cleaning with dyes and perfumes removed.

Reviewed and Consumer Reports remain my cross checks on stain performance, and New York's 1 ppm 1,4-dioxane cap stays in force with every product here on sale in the state.

For Taiwan readers heading through typhoon season and indoor drying, Costco Taiwan's 5.73 liter Kirkland jug is the direct local route to the winner.

My verdict: Kirkland for everyday loads, and Tide Ultra Oxi when the stain matters.

Kirkland keeps first at 9.1

12 to 14 cents a load from a 146 load jug keeps it on top of the cost column.

Cooler water favours liquids

Powders dissolve less reliably below 60 degrees Fahrenheit, so concentrated liquids are my autumn default.

Tide Ultra Oxi for sports season

Enzymes plus an oxygen booster handle grass, food and mud stains for about 23 cents a load.

Free & Gentle for sensitive skin

Tide Free & Gentle Plus Ultra Oxi at 8.0 keeps Ultra Oxi cleaning with dyes and perfumes removed.

2026-09-14

The ranking holds, and Kirkland Signature Ultra Clean stays first at 9.1. It is Costco's HE liquid detergent in a 194 fl oz jug rated for 146 loads, and it lands between 12 and 14 cents a load. I rank it first because cost per load follows you through every wash of the year, and Kirkland leads that column while posting solid independent stain results.

RefillWatch's 2026 cost per load guide puts that in household terms. A family running 400 loads a year that moves from Tide Pods at 43 cents a load to Kirkland liquid at 12 cents saves $124 a year on a single product. The same guide puts a 200 load box of Kirkland or Arm & Hammer powder around 10 cents a load, with a caution that powders dissolve less reliably below 60 degrees Fahrenheit. For cold water households, that caution is exactly why I weight cold wash performance and keep liquids at the top.

Tide Ultra Oxi holds second at 9.0. It is Tide's enzyme and oxygen booster liquid, and it earns its roughly 23 cents a load on grass, blood and food stains, where a second wash would cost more than the premium. Persil ProClean Original stays third at 8.7 as the strongest mainstream alternative at around 20 cents.

Reviewed's 2026 detergent roundup is a useful second opinion on stain performance, and nothing this week moves a score. New York's 1 ppm 1,4-dioxane cap remains in force with DEC's waiver program closed, and every product here is still sold in the state.

For Taiwan readers, Costco Taiwan's 5.73 liter Kirkland jug remains the direct local route to the winner.

My verdict is simple. Use Kirkland for everyday loads, and reach for Tide Ultra Oxi when the stain matters.

Kirkland Ultra Clean holds first

A 194 fl oz jug rated for 146 loads at 12 to 14 cents a load keeps it at 9.1.

$124 a year from one switch

RefillWatch's 2026 guide shows a 400 load household moving from Tide Pods at 43 cents to Kirkland liquid at 12 cents saves $124 annually.

Powder is cheap, cold water is the catch

RefillWatch puts 200 load powders near 10 cents a load and flags weaker dissolving below 60 degrees Fahrenheit.

Tide Ultra Oxi for serious stains

At about 23 cents a load it holds second at 9.0 on grass, blood and food stains.

Taiwan route to the winner

Costco Taiwan's 5.73 liter Kirkland jug is the direct local purchase.

2026-09-11

Start with the division, because this category hides its real price behind the shelf tag. Kirkland Signature Ultra Clean ships 194 fl oz rated for 146 loads and lands between 12 and 14 cents a load. Tide Ultra Oxi in the 154 fl oz bottle claims 100 loads and sits near 23 cents. Tide Evo tiles come out around 48 to 62 cents per recommended load. That is close to a fivefold spread across products that all end up in the same drum of cold water for the same forty minutes, and the number printed on the front of the bottle tells you none of it.

The costliest trap in this aisle lives inside one brand. At Walmart a 92 fl oz bottle of Tide Original at $11.97 for 64 loads prices out at 18.7 cents a load. The 50 fl oz bottle of the identical formula at $8.97 for 32 loads prices out at 28 cents. Same front label, same liquid, 50 percent apart. I built the cost per load column first for exactly this reason, and I want readers carrying that one division into the store.

My second column is New York's 1,4-dioxane rule, which became a clean binary in 2026. Household cleansing products sold in the state have been capped at 1 ppm since December 31, 2023, and DEC's finalized regulations close the waiver program, with no waiver effective after December 30, 2025. Every product here is still on New York shelves, which stands as the manufacturer's own representation that it meets the cap. Published third-party values stay scarce, so I treat a missing test result as information in its own right. The greenwashing class actions against Gain and Arm & Hammer Clean Burst rest on 2022 testing at 3.32 ppm and 4.28 ppm, both predating the cap, and both cases remain open with no final judgment.

Third is format. Consumer Reports tested 14 sheets and tiles in 2026. Tide Evo Free & Gentle took the top score in that group on blood, grass and dirt, with coffee and chocolate surviving the wash across the whole category. Arm & Hammer Power Sheets came second and cleared chocolate. Both deliver cardboard packaging, travel convenience and cold water dissolving, and both charge two to three times per load for it. That price is why the liquids hold the top six spots here.

Verdict: Kirkland Signature Ultra Clean wins 2026 on arithmetic that is not close. Tide Ultra Oxi earns the premium on the days the stain actually matters.

Kirkland Signature Ultra Clean wins 2026, and the arithmetic is not close

A 194 fl oz jug rated for 146 loads puts this between 12 and 14 cents a load, which is roughly half of what Tide Ultra Oxi costs to run and about a quarter of a Tide Evo tile. It earns the outright win on performance too: Consumer Reports places it inside the top five for stain removal, with a top score on salad dressing and strong results on body oil. For the ordinary mixed load of office shirts, school clothes and towels, which is the overwhelming majority of what any household washes, this is the detergent I recommend. Costco membership is the only real gate, and in Taiwan the same jug sits on the shelf at NT$459 for 146 loads, which works out to about NT$3.1 a wash.

Tide Ultra Oxi earns 23 cents a load on the days the stain actually matters

P&G puts the highest concentration of surfactants and enzymes it sells into this bottle, and the built-in pre-treaters handle set-in stains in a single step. Across independent stain panels Tide and Persil trade the lead, with Persil averaging about 2 percent more stains removed. Twenty-three cents a load is roughly double the Kirkland number, so my recommendation is to run the cheap bottle as the household default and keep one Ultra Oxi jug for blood, grass, body oil and anything that has already been through a dryer. Buy the 154 fl oz size and the premium per load stays at its lowest.

The 50 oz Tide bottle costs 50 percent more per load than the 92 oz bottle of the same formula

At Walmart the 92 fl oz Tide Original at $11.97 for 64 loads runs 18.7 cents a load. The 50 fl oz version of the identical liquid at $8.97 for 32 loads runs 28 cents. The packaging is the same colour, the same logo and the same claims, and the only thing separating the two numbers is a division nobody performs in the aisle. This pattern repeats across brands and it is the single highest return habit a reader can pick up from this page: divide price by the stated load count before the bottle goes in the cart. P&G's mid single digit price increases from August 2025, taken to offset about $1 billion in fiscal 2026 tariff costs, landed hardest on premium and innovation items including Tide Evo and Tide Pods with Oxi Boost, which widens these gaps further.

New York's no-waiver deadline turned 1,4-dioxane into a yes-or-no fact for 2026

Household cleansing products sold in New York have been limited to 1 ppm of 1,4-dioxane since December 31, 2023, and the DEC regulations finalized in September 2024 end the waiver pathway, with no waiver effective after December 30, 2025. For 2026 that means a detergent on a New York shelf carries the manufacturer's own representation of compliance, which is a firmer signal than any marketing claim on the front panel. Published third-party numbers remain rare, and I score a missing test value as a real gap. The Gain and Arm & Hammer Clean Burst greenwashing class actions cite 2022 independent testing at 3.32 ppm and 4.28 ppm respectively, both measured before the cap took effect, and both actions are pending with no final judgment.

Tiles and sheets buy packaging and convenience at two to three times the price per load

Consumer Reports tested 14 sheet and tile products in 2026. Tide Evo Free & Gentle earned the highest score in that group, removing blood, grass and dirt, with coffee and chocolate surviving the wash for the category as a whole. Arm & Hammer Power Sheets finished second and cleared chocolate stains. Tide Evo is genuinely the most convincing engineering in this format, six cleaning layers spun into fibre, cardboard packaging, no plastic bottle, and faster dissolving than a pod. P&G quotes about 48 cents per recommended load. That is three to four times the Kirkland figure, so I recommend the format to travellers, dorm residents and anyone hauling laundry to a shared machine, and I recommend liquid to everybody washing at home.

Taiwan readers: Costco is the only channel where this ranking's winner is an official local price

Most of the US names on this list reach Taiwan through parallel imports, which is why their prices here are marked as estimates. Costco Taiwan is the exception, listing the Kirkland Signature 5.73 L jug at NT$459 with a stated 146 washes at the level one cup mark, which is about NT$3.1 a load and the same arithmetic win it scores in the US. Taiwan also runs a different regulatory frame: there is no local household-cleanser equivalent of New York's 1 ppm cap, the TFDA residue limit for 1,4-dioxane applies to cosmetics, and the Ministry of Environment's Green Mark specification carries its own restricted substance list for cleaning products. Readers who want a third-party screen locally should look for the Green Mark, then run the same price divided by stated washes calculation on whatever is on the shelf.