2026-10-05
Made In's Stainless Clad 10-Piece keeps first place today at 9.3, and EWG's coverage of California's new PFAS labeling law is the reference that matters most for where this whole category is heading. The law requires clearer disclosure of PFAS content in cookware sold in California, and it is why every set in my top eight already scores a perfect 10.0 on PFAS compliance, stainless and cast iron simply have nothing to disclose. That uniformity at the top is exactly why Made In wins on the columns that actually separate good stainless from great stainless, a 9.6 heat tolerance score and 9.4 heat performance score that edge out All-Clad's otherwise nearly identical 9.5 and 9.6.
Kitchen Marks' PFAS-free buying guide is useful for the coated cookware further down this list, and it explains why HexClad sits at ninth with a 9.5 PFAS compliance score, just short of a perfect 10.0. Its hybrid surface uses a textured metal pattern over a stainless base, which the guide flags as a different category from true nonstick ceramic coatings like Caraway's and Our Place's.
Tramontina's Tri-Ply Clad at third remains the value pick I point budget-conscious cooks toward, a 9.8 cost-per-year score, the best on this list outside Lodge's cast iron, means you get stainless-clad performance without All-Clad pricing. For anyone replacing a coated set that has worn out, this is still where I would start.
California's PFAS law explains the top-eight uniformity
EWG's coverage of the new disclosure law is why stainless and cast iron sets all score a perfect 10.0 on PFAS compliance. There is nothing to disclose, which pushes the real competition onto heat performance.
Made In edges All-Clad on heat, not on chemistry
Both score a perfect 10.0 on PFAS compliance. Made In's advantage is a 9.6 heat tolerance score against All-Clad's 9.5, a small but real margin.
HexClad's hybrid surface is a different category
Kitchen Marks' guide flags textured hybrid metal surfaces as a distinct category from true nonstick coatings, which is why HexClad's PFAS compliance score lands at 9.5, just short of a perfect 10.0.