2026-10-05
PSA stays first today at 9.0, and the number driving that score cuts both ways. Athlon Sports reports PSA's backlog has climbed to roughly 14 million cards, which is the clearest sign yet of why PSA's resale value score sits at a perfect 10.0 while its turnaround score sits at a mediocre 6.5. Collectors keep sending cards to PSA because a PSA 10 still commands the biggest premium on the secondary market, and that premium is exactly what keeps the backlog growing. I am not changing PSA's rank over a backlog number alone, resale value is doing the heaviest lifting in my formula and nothing here threatens that.
SGC's price increase, reported by Sports Illustrated, is the more interesting signal for the middle of this table. SGC sits third at 8.1, with the best trust score outside PSA and BGS, and raising prices while keeping turnaround reasonably fast tells me the company is managing demand on its own terms. That is a healthier position than PSA's, even if SGC will never match PSA's resale multiplier.
CGC Trading Cards continues to hold second at 8.5 on the strength of balanced scores across every column, trust, pricing and turnaround all land above 7.5, and its availability score of 9.5 reflects a company that has not let volume outrun its infrastructure the way PSA has. For anyone grading a card specifically to sell it, I would still point first-time submitters toward CGC or SGC over a PSA queue that, by Athlon's count, is now measured in years for some tiers.
PSA's 14 million card backlog is the cost of being the standard
Athlon Sports confirms the backlog keeps growing because a PSA 10 still carries the biggest resale premium. That premium is why PSA stays first despite a 6.5 turnaround score.
SGC's price increase signals discipline, not just demand
Sports Illustrated reports SGC raised prices while holding turnaround steady. That is why SGC holds third at 8.1 with the best trust score outside PSA and BGS.
CGC is still my pick for a seller in a hurry
Second place at 8.5 comes from balance, not one standout column. Every factor sits above 7.5, and 9.5 on availability means capacity has not fallen behind demand.